When Nintendo stunned the industry by tagging Mario Kart World at $80, murmurs rippled across game studios and among fans alike: who’ll be next? Gearbox boss Randy Pitchford didn’t dodge the question at PAX East—he leaned into it, admitting that Borderlands 4’s sticker price is still up in the air.

Pitchford was candid about the decision-making process. He doesn’t have the number yet, he said; that call lies with the publishing side. Between rising tariffs and an R&D budget that’s “more than twice” what Borderlands 3 demanded, the price tag could well rise to match Nintendo’s bold new benchmark—or Gearbox might hang back. As Pitchford quipped:

“We’re gonna have a price set soon. (It) might be the new price that Nintendo and Microsoft have led with, (or) it might be that we stay back. It’s gonna be the people at the publishing house that decide that. If it is cheaper, maybe we’ll sell you that minimap that you guys want that we’ll develop later. How bad you want that? $10? I don’t know. I’m just kidding.”

Even in jest, his comment underscores a core tension: studios need revenue to fund ever-growing development costs, but they also want players to feel they’re getting a fair deal. That balance is at the heart of Pitchford’s “fundamental philosophy”:

“We want people to buy it so we have the resources to make more, but we want everyone who buys and plays a Gearbox game to feel certain that they got the better end of the bargain.”

In this piece, we’ll unpack what’s at stake here: why games keep getting pricier, who really pulls the pricing levers, and what it all means for players excited—or nervous—about Borderlands 4.

The Rising Cost of Making Triple‑A Games

Budgets Ballooning Beyond Imagination

Over the last decade, blockbuster game budgets have exploded. Gone are the days when a few dozen developers could build a sprawling open‑world epic. Today, teams of hundreds juggle high‑def voice acting, photorealistic graphics, and elaborate live‑service hooks. Pitchford’s own admission that Borderlands 4’s development costs more than doubled from the previous entry isn’t unique—many studios are in the same boat.

• Talent and Tools: Top‑tier engines like Unreal or custom in‑house software come with licensing fees and require specialists.
• Global Supply Chains: From art outsourcing in Eastern Europe to voiceover sessions in Los Angeles, geopolitical tensions and shipping slowdowns drive up costs.
• Tariffs and Taxes: New tariffs on electronics and software imports mean hardware and licensing components are pricier—a direct hit to the bottom line.

The Impact of Tariffs on Price Tags

Pitchford flagged tariffs as a big unknown. When countries impose levies on imported chips or consoles, manufacturers pass costs downstream to publishers. Publishers then pass them to consumers. That domino effect has already nudged console prices upward and, now, these higher costs are bleeding into game pricing discussions.

Nintendo’s $80 Gamble: Industry Shockwave

When Nintendo announced Mario Kart World at $80—20 percent above the now‑standard $60‑$70 range—heads turned. Players braced for the worst; studios wondered if Nintendo would get away with it.

• Why $80? Nintendo pointed to a huge investment in HD assets, revamped physics, and online infrastructure. They also hinted tariffs could push console and accessory prices higher.
• Initial Fan Reaction: Backlash on social media ranged from anger to resigned acceptance. Some fans vowed to pirate rather than pay up.
• Other Publishers: Microsoft and Ubisoft quietly prepped similar hikes for major titles, citing similar cost pressures.

Nintendo’s move gave cover to other publishers debating the same question: is your audience prepared to pay more for premium content? For a beloved franchise like Borderlands, with its loyal fanbase, Gearbox probably has more leeway than most—but the optics still matter.

Who Actually Sets the Price?

Developers vs. Publishers

Pitchford stressed the decision won’t be his. “It’s gonna be the people at the publishing house that decide that.” This split—development studios vs. publishers—is where pricing battles often rage.

• Developers want creative freedom and enough budget to innovate. They’ll advocate for prices that cover costs without alienating fans.
• Publishers focus on revenue projections, market positioning, and shareholder expectations. They may push for premium pricing to hit quarterly targets.

Sometimes, developers lobby for in‑game add‑ons—season passes, cosmetic packs—to offset a lower base price. Pitchford’s joked offer to sell a minimap later for $10 illustrates this dynamic: if the base price is lower, DLC opportunities increase.

Market Psychology: Value vs. Price

Psychologists have long studied how consumers perceive price. A higher tag can imply premium quality—unless the product fails to meet expectations. For Borderlands 4, any hike must be justified by a clear leap in scope, features, or lasting play value.

• Perceived Value: Are players getting hours of unique content, co‑op innovations, or a robust live‑service model?
• Comparative Pricing: Will they balk if Borderlands 4 costs more than other open‑world shooters? Or will they shrug, given they invest hundreds of hours per playthrough?

What Players Want (and Worry About)

Core Concerns from the Community

Borderlands fans are passionate. They’ll scrutinize everything from story beats to loot rarity. When pricing enters the conversation, concerns often boil down to:

1. Overpriced Base Game: Paying $80 only to find out the real meat of the experience lives in paid expansions.
2. Microtransactions: Will a higher entry point mean more aggressive in‑game purchases?
3. Quality Justification: Do the graphics, story, and mechanics genuinely leap forward enough to merit a jump from $60 to $80?

Developer Transparency as a Buffer

Some studios have begun sharing budget breakdowns or dev diaries to justify higher tags. If Gearbox publishes behind‑the‑scenes videos showing how each dollar is spent—capturing motion actors, creating new planets, refining co‑op scaling—it may soften the blow.

Balancing Act: Making More vs. Keeping Fans Happy

Pitchford distilled Workshop’s ethos: they need people to buy the game so they can make more games. But they also want every player to feel they snagged a bargain.

“We want people to buy it so we have the resources to make more, but we want everyone who buys and plays a Gearbox game to feel certain that they got the better end of the bargain.”

This two‑pronged goal means:

• Investing in Post‑Launch Support: Free updates, quality‑of‑life patches, community‑driven events.
• Fair DLC Pricing: If additional maps or story arcs arrive later, they should cost reasonable amounts relative to their content.
• Cross‑Generational Access: Bundled upgrade paths for PS4/PS5, Xbox One/Series X|S players can soften the blow of a higher new‑gen price.

What This Means for Borderlands 4

Possible Scenarios

1. $80 Launch: Align with Nintendo and follow Microsoft’s lead. Gearbox offers a deluxe edition with exclusive skins or early‑access DLC.
2. $70 Middle Ground: A smaller hike, positioning Borderlands 4 as a premium title but slightly under Nintendo’s new high‑water mark.
3. Stay at $60: Absorb extra costs, betting that goodwill and strong sales volume make up for slimmer margins.

Pitchford’s minimap gag hints at creative compromises: if the base price stays lower, players may purchase optional extras later. That would shift some revenue post‑launch, spreading development costs over DLC sales.

Tariffs Still in Play

Nintendo also signaled it might adjust the Switch 2 console price depending on how tariffs shake out. If hardware costs relent, game prices could stabilize. Gearbox will be watching global trade talks as closely as its internal budget discussions.

Related

Doom: The Dark Ages’ Exclusive Ranger Skin Comes with Pizza

"Unlock exclusive Doom skin with spicy pizza promo now!"

Looking Ahead

As Borderlands 4 barrels toward release later this year, the community will watch every sign: pre‑order tiers, collector’s edition bundles, and any teases of post‑launch content. Will the game’s ambitious budget and burgeoning costs translate into sticker shock? Or will Gearbox find a sweet spot that keeps players eager and publishers satisfied?

One thing’s clear: in an era of ever‑higher budgets and uncertain supply chains, the old $59.99 benchmark feels quaint. Whether Borderlands 4 follows Nintendo’s $80 lead, settles in the $70 bracket, or bucks the trend, it will reveal a lot about where the industry—and fandom—stand on value, quality, and trust.